See all results on the search page

    Theological Views

    Evangelical vs Progressive Christianity

    Evangelical statements of faith teach that the Bible is God's inspired, trustworthy word, and that Jesus was born of a virgin, died in place of sinners, rose bodily, and saves those who trust in him. One group's statement, ProgressiveChristianity.org's, which the group calls not dogma but a starting point, centers the way of Jesus, inclusion, openness to other faiths, and questions over certainty; writers such as Marcus Borg read the Bible as a human witness to God.

    • 26 minute read
    • 61 sources
    • Last reviewed:

    Evangelical Christianity

    Progressive Christianity

    On this page the first-named side is shown in teal and the second in copper. The colors mark the two sides only.

    Who counts as evangelical, and who counts as progressive?

    Surveys count evangelicals by their beliefs or by the churches they belong to. This page describes progressive Christians through one organization's statement and several writers. Both labels are disputed, so this page names the body or writer behind every view.

    The historian David Bebbington named four marks of evangelicals: conversionism, the belief that lives need to be changed; biblicism, a high regard for the Bible; activism, spreading the gospel through mission and reform; and crucicentrism, a stress on Jesus's death on the cross. The National Association of Evangelicals (NAE) gives these four marks and says it brings together 40 denominations from Reformed, Holiness, Anabaptist, Pentecostal, Charismatic, and other traditions.1 Evangelicals are spread across many churches, denominations, and nations.1 Their statements of faith include the NAE's, the Lausanne Covenant of 1974, and the Southern Baptist Convention's Baptist Faith and Message 2000, and they differ in places.234

    ProgressiveChristianity.org has published a statement of progressive Christian values since 1997.5 It began in 1994 as The Center for Progressive Christianity, founded by Jim Adams, then rector of St. Mark's Church on Capitol Hill in Washington, who gathered about a dozen scholars at the Episcopal seminary in Cambridge, Massachusetts, to draft its Eight Points.6 The points were revised in 2003 and 2011, and the 2022 version, the Core Values, has five.57 The organization calls them not dogma but a starting point for conversation, and says people need not agree with every word.7

    Three scholars reviewing research on religion in progressive politics wrote in 2018 that progressive religious voices are more widespread and more diverse than is commonly recognized, and less studied.8 No survey this page found measures how many progressive Christians share any one writer's views. Where no statement speaks, this page gives several progressive writers in their own words or their publishers'.

    Marcus Borg was a New Testament scholar, called by the foundation that carries on his work one of the most widely known voices in progressive Christianity.9 John Shelby Spong led the Episcopal Diocese of Newark from 1979 for more than two decades, and Religion News Service said he was known for his progressive theology.10 Brian McLaren is an author and former pastor, and Publishers Weekly described one of his books as progressive theology in a popular idiom.1112 Rachel Held Evans grew up in an evangelical home. NPR called her a progressive Christian writer, known for her progressive activism in the evangelical church.13 Some of her writing cited here, from 2009 to 2012, takes positions that two groups on this page's evangelical side, BioLogos and Christians for Biblical Equality, also hold.14151617

    The two groups are counted in different ways. Pew Research Center's Religious Landscape Study, surveyed in 2023 and 2024, counts 23 percent of US adults as evangelical Protestants. It sorts people mainly by the denomination they name, and sorts those who name none by whether they call themselves born-again or evangelical and by race and ethnicity.18 A 2015 survey by Lifeway Research, using a definition drawn up with the NAE, counted by belief instead. About 3 in 10 Americans strongly agreed with all four of its statements, on the Bible, evangelism, Jesus's death, and salvation, while only 59 percent of Protestants who called themselves evangelicals did.19

    Neither Pew nor PRRI counts progressive Christians as a group. Pew sorts Protestants into evangelical, mainline, and historically Black traditions; none is a progressive tradition.20 In 2013 PRRI built a scale from theological, economic, and social views and counted 19 percent of Americans as religious progressives. That group was not limited to Christians or to one kind of church: 29 percent were Catholics, 19 percent white mainline Protestants, and 13 percent members of non-Christian faiths.21 So progressive is not another name for mainline, which is Pew's name for a group of denominations such as the United Methodist Church, the Episcopal Church, and the United Church of Christ.20

    Most of the surveys and sources on this page come from the United States. The evangelical movement is wider: the World Evangelical Alliance said on its website in 2026 that it represents more than 650 million evangelical Christians through 164 national alliances.22 Many Christians stand between the camps: Marcus Borg, describing a divide among American Christians over whether Christianity is the only way of salvation, noted that many are in the middle.23 The labels also do not always match belief: in the 2015 survey, only 25 percent of African Americans who held the four evangelical beliefs called themselves evangelical.19

    At a glance

    TopicsEvangelical ChristianityProgressive ChristianityFull section
    The Bible: God's word, human words, and how to read themEvangelical statements call the Bible God's inspired word; Lausanne says it is without error in all it affirms, and the Chicago Statement extends that to history and science.The Core Values do not mention the Bible; Marcus Borg called it a human product and yet a treasure, the witness of spiritual ancestors to God, to be read historically and metaphorically.Read the full section: The Bible: God's word, human words, and how to read them
    Jesus: who he was, and what Easter meansThe NAE affirms Jesus's deity, his virgin birth and miracles, and his bodily resurrection from the dead.Marcus Borg and John Shelby Spong held Easter true without a physical resurrection; Brian McLaren makes room both for literal readings and for others.Read the full section: Jesus: who he was, and what Easter means
    The meaning of Jesus's deathEvangelical statements teach that Jesus died in sinners' place to remove the penalty of sin, a view called penal substitution; the authors of a 2006 four-views book debate how central it is.Borg called the payment view a serious distortion; Spong argued that atonement theology presents God as barbaric; McLaren came to question it.Read the full section: The meaning of Jesus's death
    Salvation and other religionsSouthern Baptist teaching finds no salvation apart from new birth and personal faith in Jesus; evangelicals differ on whether the lost suffer forever.Every version of ProgressiveChristianity.org's points recognizes other faiths; the 2022 Core Values see the Spirit at work in other traditions.Read the full section: Salvation and other religions
    The church's mission: evangelism, justice, and welcomeLausanne counts evangelism and social action as duties and calls evangelism primary; the Cape Town Commitment speaks of integral mission.ProgressiveChristianity.org's points center justice, peace, care for the Earth, and an open welcome; no version names evangelism as a goal.Read the full section: The church's mission: evangelism, justice, and welcome
    Faith and science, including creation and evolutionAnswers in Genesis teaches six-day creation, BioLogos accepts evolution as God's method, and white evangelicals' survey answers turn on wording.The Core Values describe progressive Christians as embracing contemporary science; Rachel Held Evans, crediting BioLogos's founder, came to see evolution as a viable account of how God created; Spong called the fall story pre-Darwinian mythology.Read the full section: Faith and science, including creation and evolution
    Certainty, doubt, and questionsStatements speak of the Spirit's assurance and of believers kept to the end; the pastor Tim Keller urged believers to face their doubts.ProgressiveChristianity.org's points find more grace in the search than in certainty, and more value in questioning than in absolutes.Read the full section: Certainty, doubt, and questions
    Women in church leadershipDivided: Danvers and the Southern Baptists restrict some church roles to men; Christians for Biblical Equality and the Assemblies of God do not.ProgressiveChristianity.org's points have welcomed women and men alike since 1997; Rachel Held Evans made the egalitarian case from scripture in 2012; Spong championed women clergy.Read the full section: Women in church leadership
    Marriage, sexuality, and abortionSouthern Baptist teaching sets marriage between one man and one woman and protects life from conception; in Pew's survey, sizable minorities of evangelicals differ.ProgressiveChristianity.org's points have welcomed gay and straight people since 1997, and all sexual orientations since 2003; Rebecca Todd Peters argues for trusting women's own decisions on abortion.Read the full section: Marriage, sexuality, and abortion
    How each sees the otherThe Presbyterian scholar J. Gresham Machen (1923) called the liberal theology of his day a different religion; the professor Scot McKnight answered Brian McLaren by name.Borg described a struggle over the heart and soul of Christianity; the 1997 Eight Points place progressives in the church's tradition.Read the full section: How each sees the other

    The Bible: God's word, human words, and how to read them

    Evangelical statements hold the Bible to be God's inspired word, and most of those cited here call it without error; Marcus Borg wrote that not affirming inerrancy is one of the defining marks of progressive Christianity.

    The NAE's Statement of Faith says the Bible is inspired by God and is his only infallible and authoritative word.2 The Lausanne Covenant says scripture is without error in all that it affirms and is the only infallible rule of faith and practice.3 The Baptist Faith and Message 2000 says the Bible was written by divinely inspired human authors and has God for its author, that it is truth without any mixture of error, and that Jesus is the focus of divine revelation.4

    The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy (1978) goes further. It holds that the Bible is free of error in history and science as well as in faith, that inspiration, strictly speaking, applies only to the original text, and that each passage should be read by its grammar, history, and literary form.24 Its signers did not intend it as a creed.24 Evangelicals word this differently: the NAE's statement says infallible and does not use the word inerrant, while the Chicago Statement holds that the two can be told apart but not separated.224

    ProgressiveChristianity.org's Core Values do not mention the Bible; they center on following the way and teachings of Jesus.7 Marcus Borg wrote that all of the Bible is a human product, and yet a treasure carried in earthen vessels. He called it the witness of spiritual ancestors, ancient Israelites and early Christians, recording their experiences along with their limits, and he questioned whether calling it the word of God, or inspired, requires holding that it has no errors.25

    In Reading the Bible Again for the First Time (2001), Borg told of unlearning the literal reading he grew up with, and proposed a historical-metaphorical reading: what a text meant in its ancient setting, and what meanings reach beyond it.26 Rachel Held Evans's Inspired (2018) asks what the Bible is, if not a science book or an instruction manual; her publisher says she found a living book that can inspire readers to join God's redemptive work.27 John Shelby Spong argued that ancient codes, the Ten Commandments and the Sermon on the Mount among them, cannot settle today's moral questions.28

    Jesus: who he was, and what Easter means

    Evangelical statements affirm Jesus's virgin birth, miracles, and bodily resurrection as events; Marcus Borg and John Shelby Spong held that Easter is true without depending on a physical resurrection, and Brian McLaren makes room for both readings.

    The NAE's Statement of Faith affirms Jesus's deity. It holds that he was born of a virgin, lived without sin, worked miracles, died an atoning death, rose bodily from the dead, ascended to heaven, and will return in power and glory.2 The Baptist Faith and Message 2000 calls him fully God and fully man. It says Jesus was conceived of the Holy Spirit and born of the virgin Mary, and that he was raised from the dead with a glorified body and appeared to his disciples as the same person who was with them before his crucifixion.4

    The Baptist Faith and Message adds that Jesus is now exalted at God's right hand as the one mediator, in whose person God and humanity are reconciled. It says he will return in power and glory to judge the world, and that he now dwells in all believers as the living and ever-present Lord.4 J. Gresham Machen, a Presbyterian scholar who taught at Princeton Theological Seminary, held in 1923 that Christianity rests on an account of events that took place in the first century.2930

    The Core Values speak of following the way and teachings of Jesus, and do not mention his birth or his resurrection.7 Marcus Borg held that a Christian can fully embrace Easter without believing in a physical bodily resurrection. He noted that the apostle Paul31 called the resurrection body spiritual, and read Mark's empty tomb story as a parable whose meaning does not depend on whether the tomb was empty.3233 Borg regarded it as a fact of history that Jesus's followers experienced him after his death as a living presence, and for him Easter means that Jesus lives and is Lord.3233

    John Shelby Spong held that the Easter event transformed the Christian movement but did not mean the physical return of Jesus's dead body to life, and that the virgin birth cannot be literal biology.28 Brian McLaren, asked on his podcast in 2023 about the virgin birth and the resurrection, said he did not want to take a literal reading from those who hold one, and was fine with those for whom it is a barrier; he is interested in the meaning.34

    The meaning of Jesus's death

    Evangelical statements teach that Jesus died in sinners' place to remove the penalty of sin; Marcus Borg and John Shelby Spong rejected that payment view, Brian McLaren came to question it, and Borg read the cross as an execution by the ruling powers.

    The NAE's Statement of Faith affirms Jesus's death as atoning, in the place of others, through his shed blood.2 The Baptist Faith and Message 2000 says that in his substitutionary death on the cross Jesus made provision for redemption from sin.4 The NAE and Lifeway belief definition asks whether Jesus's death is the only sacrifice that could remove the penalty of sin.1 This view, in which Jesus bears the penalty of sin in the sinner's place, is called penal substitution.35

    The four authors of The Nature of the Atonement: Four Views (2006) debate how central it is. Tom Schreiner defends penal substitution, Greg Boyd Christus Victor, which sees the cross as victory over evil powers, Bruce Reichenbach a healing view, and Joel Green a kaleidoscopic view that holds many images together.3635 Greg Gilbert, a Baptist pastor reviewing the book for 9Marks, argued that the real question is whether Jesus's death was penal and substitutionary.35 Crossway, the publisher of Pierced for Our Transgressions (2007), says its authors make the case that scripture teaches the doctrine, that its pedigree is impeccable, and that it is central to Christian theology; it adds that they analyze more than twenty objections.37

    The Core Values do not mention the cross.7 Marcus Borg called the payment understanding, in which Jesus dies to pay for human sin, a serious distortion of the cross's meaning, because it implies that God willed Jesus's death.38 He wrote that the theologian Anselm of Canterbury39 first fully set out the payment view in 1098, and that in the church's first thousand years it was at most a minor metaphor.38 In his reading, the Gospels show Jesus executed by the powers that ruled his world because of his witness against them, and Easter as God's yes to Jesus and what he stood for.38

    John Shelby Spong argued that atonement theology, especially in its substitutionary form, pictures God as barbaric, Jesus as a victim, and human beings as guilt-filled creatures.28 Brian McLaren wrote in a 2012 foreword to Derek Flood's Healing the Gospel that, growing up evangelical, he took penal substitution to be the gospel itself. An evangelical theologian's question, whether Jesus should define the gospel, turned him to Jesus's message of the kingdom of God; a few years later, another evangelical theologian's remark set him rethinking the doctrine. He judged the book's alternative to penal substitution more faithful to scripture.40

    Salvation and other religions

    Evangelical statements teach that salvation comes only through personal faith in Jesus; ProgressiveChristianity.org's statements recognize other faiths, and its 2022 Core Values see the Spirit at work in them.

    The NAE's statement holds that regeneration by the Holy Spirit is essential for salvation, and that the saved and the lost will both be raised, some to life and some to damnation.2 The Baptist Faith and Message 2000 calls regeneration the new birth, a change of heart brought about by the Spirit, to which a person responds in repentance and faith. It says there is no salvation apart from personal faith in Jesus Christ as Lord, and that the unrighteous will be sent to hell, the place of everlasting punishment.4

    The Lausanne Covenant teaches that people can know something of God through nature, but that this knowledge cannot save. It rejects universalism, the view that everyone will in the end be saved, and any dialogue that implies Christ speaks equally through all religions.3 Evangelicals divide on the nature of hell. A 2000 report for the Evangelical Alliance in Britain called eternal conscious punishment the classic, mainstream evangelical position, and called annihilationism, the view that the lost are finally destroyed rather than punished forever, a significant minority evangelical view.4142

    ProgressiveChristianity.org's Eight Points of 1997 called Jesus the gate to the realm of God and recognized the faithfulness of those with other names for that gateway. The 2003 revision said other people's ways are true for them, as ours are true for us. The 2011 version called Jesus's teachings one of many ways to experience the sacred.5 The 2022 Core Values recognize the good work of the Spirit in other faith traditions.7

    John Shelby Spong argued that the hope of life after death must be separated forever from controlling behavior, and that traditional views of heaven and hell as places of reward and punishment are no longer conceivable.28 Marcus Borg described Christians who see Christianity as one of the world's great religions, not the only adequate revelation of God.23 Brian McLaren, interviewed by PBS in 2005 on the emerging church, a trend he described as crossing church lines, said a fair reading of the Gospels does not reduce Jesus's message to getting souls into heaven, and that for some people, though no one intends it, the traditional view of hell makes God look like a torturer.43

    The church's mission: evangelism, justice, and welcome

    Evangelical statements make evangelism, calling people to faith in Jesus, central to the church's mission alongside social action; ProgressiveChristianity.org's statements center justice, peace, care for the Earth, and an open welcome into worship and community.

    The NAE and Lifeway belief definition asks whether it is very important to encourage non-Christians to trust Jesus as their Savior.1 The Baptist Faith and Message 2000 calls Christians to win the lost by verbal witness backed by a Christian way of life.4 The Lausanne Covenant says that evangelism and socio-political involvement are both part of Christian duty, and repents of having sometimes treated evangelism and social concern as mutually exclusive.3 It also says that in the church's mission of sacrificial service, evangelism is primary.3

    Evangelical statements weigh the two in different ways. The Lausanne Movement's Cape Town Commitment of 2010 speaks of integral mission, the proclamation and demonstration of the gospel together, in which preaching has social consequences and social action has evangelistic ones.31 The Baptist Faith and Message also calls Christians to oppose racism and to care for the needy.4

    The Eight Points of 1997 invited people of all kinds into worship and common life as full partners, without requiring them to become like those already there.5 They described a community striving for justice and peace and bringing hope to those Jesus called the least of his sisters and brothers.5 The 2022 Core Values call for peace and justice among all people, name compassion and selfless love as the fullest expression of faith, and speak of striving to protect the Earth.7

    Marcus Borg asked readers to see Christianity as sharing Jesus's passion for making this world one of justice and peace.38 Brian McLaren's Everything Must Change, in its publisher's words, calls the good news more than a ticket to heaven: an invitation to personal change and a radical challenge for global transformation.44 None of ProgressiveChristianity.org's versions names evangelism, calling others to faith in Jesus, as a goal.57

    Faith and science, including creation and evolution

    Evangelicals differ on how to read Genesis beside evolution, from young-earth creation to evolution as God's method of creating; ProgressiveChristianity.org describes progressive Christians as embracing the insights of contemporary science, and Spong called the story of a perfect creation and a fall pre-Darwinian mythology.

    The Chicago Statement holds that the Bible's truth covers history and science, and that scientific theories about the earth's history may not overturn scripture's teaching on creation and the flood.24 Answers in Genesis, an apologetics ministry, teaches six 24-hour days of creation, about 4,000 years from creation to Jesus, and a worldwide flood, and calls views that fit evolution or millions of years into Genesis incompatible with scripture.45 BioLogos, founded in 2007 by Francis Collins, director of the Human Genome Project, affirms evolution as God's method of creation.15

    In 2012 Christianity Today, reporting on a BioLogos conference, cited Barna Research on US Protestant pastors as a whole: more than half held to a six-day, 24-hour creation, and fewer than one in five affirmed BioLogos's view. Participants, the report said, noted that few Christian colleges teach young-earth creationism, but that grassroots efforts, often centered on homeschooling, have won most evangelicals to it.15 In a 2019 Pew study, white evangelical Protestants' answers turned on the wording: asked in two steps, 66 percent said humans have always existed in their present form, while asked one question, 62 percent said humans have evolved. Nearly all who accepted evolution said God had a role in it, and 68 percent of white evangelicals saw a wide scientific consensus on evolution.46

    The 2022 Core Values describe progressive Christians as embracing the insights of contemporary science and striving to protect the Earth.7 The 2003 and 2011 versions spoke of protecting and restoring the integrity of God's creation and of the Earth, and the 2011 version said followers can draw on diverse sources of wisdom.5 ProgressiveChristianity.org's statements do not take up evolution or the age of the earth by name.75

    John Shelby Spong began from the view that God can no longer be pictured as a supernatural being outside the world who steps in to act within it.28 He called the biblical story of a perfect creation and a fall into original sin pre-Darwinian mythology, and nonsense after Darwin.28 He held that the ascension story assumes a three-tiered universe abandoned about five centuries ago, and that miracles understood as supernatural invasions of nature are not a workable account after Newton.28

    In a 2009 blog post, Rachel Held Evans wrote that The Language of God, by Francis Collins, changed her view, and that she came to respect evolution as a viable explanation of how God created the heavens and the earth. She wrote that Genesis 1 and 2 can be read metaphorically without losing their point, that God created the universe.14

    Certainty, doubt, and questions

    Evangelical statements speak of the Spirit's assurance that scripture is true and teach that true believers are kept to the end, and the pastor Tim Keller urged believers to face their doubts; ProgressiveChristianity.org's statements value questions over certainty.

    The Chicago Statement holds that the Holy Spirit bears witness to scripture, assuring believers that God's written word is true.24 The Baptist Faith and Message 2000 teaches that all true believers endure to the end and are kept by the power of God through faith.4

    Evangelical writers such as Tim Keller also take up doubt. Keller started Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York City in 1989, a congregation Christianity Today called Reformed and evangelical, and built The Reason for God (2008) around common doubts about what orthodox Christians believe.474849 In an interview, he said that believers have doubts and ought to be more forthright in addressing them, and that doing so makes a person a better apologist, a defender of the faith. He said that reading N. T. Wright's The Resurrection of the Son of God brought him to greater certainty that Jesus rose from the dead, and eased doubts he had not known he had.49

    The Eight Points of 1997 and 2003 said progressive Christians find more grace in the search for meaning than in absolute certainty, and more in the questions than in the answers.5 The 2011 version and the 2022 Core Values say there is more value in questioning than in absolutes, and commit to life-long learning.57 The 1997 points welcomed believers and agnostics, conventional Christians and questioning skeptics, as full partners.5

    John Shelby Spong said that the older he grew, the more deeply he believed but the fewer beliefs he held, repeating an older bishop's saying. He spoke of a mystical awareness of God, and said that when asked to define God he was almost wordless.10 Rachel Held Evans's Faith Unraveled, first published in 2010 as Evolving in Monkey Town, tells, in its publisher's words, of her journey from certainty to doubt to faith, and urges trust in a God big enough to handle tough questions.5051

    Women in church leadership

    Evangelicals divide on whether women may hold every church office; ProgressiveChristianity.org's statements have welcomed women and men alike since 1997 and limit no church role by sex.

    The Danvers Statement of 1988, from the Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, holds that Adam and Eve were created equal before God in his image, that the husband's headship in marriage was set before the Fall, and that some governing and teaching roles in the church are restricted to men.52 The Baptist Faith and Message 2000, as amended in 2023, limits the office of pastor to men.4

    Christians for Biblical Equality issued its own statement in 1989. It holds that the Bible teaches the full equality of men and women in creation and redemption, and that women as well as men may carry out the church's prophetic, priestly, and royal functions.17 The Assemblies of God, which Pew counts as evangelical, ordains women. Christianity Today reported in 2022 that women were 27.6 percent of its ministers and led about 6 percent of its churches, and that women have preached in the denomination since its founding in 1914.2053

    ProgressiveChristianity.org's Eight Points of 1997 listed females and males among those invited into worship and common life as full partners, and the 2003 and 2011 versions listed women and men.5 The 2022 Core Values seek community open to all, whatever their gender identity and expression.7 None of the versions limits any role in the church by sex.57

    John Shelby Spong, as bishop of Newark, championed women clergy and required that searches for clergy in his diocese interview at least one woman.10 He argued that discrimination based on gender is evil, and that the church should expose it rather than excuse it in the name of sacred tradition.28 Rachel Held Evans made the egalitarian case from scripture: her 2012 blog series on mutuality, which featured Mimi Haddad, then president of Christians for Biblical Equality, set out to show that scripture, tradition, reason, and experience support equality for women in the home, the church, and society.1654

    Marriage, sexuality, and abortion

    Southern Baptist teaching holds marriage to be between one man and one woman and defends unborn life, though evangelicals in surveys divide; ProgressiveChristianity.org's statements welcome people of all sexual orientations, and Rebecca Todd Peters argues for trusting women's own decisions on abortion.

    The Baptist Faith and Message 2000 defines marriage as the uniting of one man and one woman in a covenant for life. It calls husbands to love their wives as Christ loved the church, and wives to submit graciously to their husbands' servant leadership.4 It calls Christians to speak on behalf of the unborn and to contend for the sanctity of all human life from conception to natural death.4

    Evangelicals do not all agree. In Pew's survey of 2023 and 2024, 62 percent of evangelical Protestants opposed same-sex marriage, and 65 percent said abortion should be illegal in all or most cases.55 That leaves sizable minorities who do not hold those positions.55 Christians for Biblical Equality, by contrast, calls husbands and wives to defer to each other.17

    Every version of ProgressiveChristianity.org's statement has welcomed people whatever their sexuality: homosexuals and heterosexuals in 1997, and people of all sexual orientations and gender identities from 2003 on.57 None of its versions mentions marriage or abortion.57 In 1989 John Shelby Spong ordained the first openly gay male priest in the Episcopal Church, and he argued that discrimination based on sexual orientation is evil.1028

    On abortion, Rebecca Todd Peters, a scholar of religious studies at Elon University and an ordained Presbyterian minister, wrote Trust Women: A Progressive Christian Argument for Reproductive Justice (2018). She argues that the starting point should be women's lives, and that society fails to trust women as capable, responsible moral agents, and she challenges the expectation that women must justify their decisions.56

    How each sees the other

    J. Gresham Machen in 1923, and later writers, have argued that liberal and progressive teaching departs from historic Christianity; Marcus Borg described a struggle over Christianity's heart and soul, and each side traces its own view to the church's past.

    Machen's Christianity and Liberalism (1923) argued that the liberal theology of his day was not a form of Christianity but a different religion. He held that its many forms share one root, naturalism, which he defined as denying that God's creative power, beyond the ordinary course of nature, entered into Christianity's origins.57 The Chicago Statement holds that inerrancy has been part of the church's faith throughout its history and was not invented by later Protestant scholars. It says confessing inerrancy is not needed for salvation, but that rejecting it has grave consequences.24 Its preface says that many who deny inerrancy do not show those consequences in their belief and behavior, and offers the statement in a spirit of humility and love rather than contention.24

    Later writers have answered progressive authors and ideas. Scot McKnight, then a professor of religion at North Park University, reviewing Brian McLaren's A New Kind of Christianity in Christianity Today in 2010, wrote that the book lacked the generosity of genuine orthodoxy.58 Alisa Childers, once a member of the Christian band ZOEgirl, wrote Another Gospel? (2020) in response to progressive Christianity.59 Her website says her faith was challenged when she met a progressive pastor who called himself a hopeful agnostic, and that the book tells of her years of wrestling with questions at the core of the faith.60

    Marcus Borg described American Christians as deeply divided. On one side he placed absolutist Christians, who hold Christianity to be the one absolute revelation of God and the only way of salvation, often with a literal reading of the Bible; on the other, Christians who see it as one of the world's great religions. He counted believers in papal as well as biblical infallibility in the first camp, and called it a struggle over the heart and soul of Christianity.23

    The Eight Points of 1997 called costly discipleship, the renouncing of privilege, and conscientious resistance to evil the church's tradition all along.5 Rachel Held Evans wrote of a Holy Week that included Easter at her childhood evangelical church. She listed moments of faith and of connection, such as worshiping beside fellow Christians, and moments of disconnect, among them hearing the gospel reduced to salvation from hell and welcomes that felt patronizing from people praying she would go back to believing, behaving, and voting as they did. She called it a week of great joy and of frustration.61 Religion News Service reported that critics saw Spong as preaching something different from Christianity, and as failing a bishop's charge to defend the faith; he answered that with all his heart he thought he was a Christian.10

    Where they agree

    Both sides center their faith on Jesus. The NAE's statement affirms Jesus's deity, and the Core Values begin with following his way and teachings.27 Both traditions have spoken of sharing bread and the cup in Jesus's name, and understand the meal in their own ways: Southern Baptists as a memorial of his death that looks ahead to his return, and the 1997 and 2003 Eight Points as a picture of God's feast for all peoples.45

    Both call for justice and care for people in need. The Baptist Faith and Message tells Christians to oppose racism and provide for the needy, the Lausanne Covenant counts socio-political involvement as Christian duty, and the Core Values call for peace and justice among all people.437 Each side also places itself in the church's long tradition: the Chicago Statement for inerrancy, and the 1997 Eight Points for costly discipleship.245

    Where they divide

    They divide first on the Bible. The Lausanne Covenant holds it to be without error in all that it affirms, and the Baptist Faith and Message holds it to be truth without any mixture of error, while Marcus Borg called all of it a human product and yet a treasure, the witness of spiritual ancestors to their experience of God.3425 They divide on the virgin birth, which the NAE affirms and Spong held cannot be literal biology, and on Easter, which the NAE affirms as a bodily resurrection and Borg and Spong held true without depending on one.22832 They divide on the cross, where the Baptist Faith and Message teaches a substitutionary death, Borg and Spong rejected that view, and McLaren came to question it.4382840

    They divide on salvation, where the Baptist Faith and Message finds no salvation apart from personal faith in Jesus and the Core Values see the Spirit at work in other traditions.47 And they divide on sexuality and abortion: Southern Baptist teaching defines marriage as the uniting of one man and one woman and defends unborn life, while ProgressiveChristianity.org's statements welcome people of all sexual orientations, and Rebecca Todd Peters argues for trusting women's own decisions on abortion.45756

    Each camp also has its own divisions. Evangelicals divide over women's leadership, evolution, and hell, and in surveys over same-sex marriage and abortion.17464155 ProgressiveChristianity.org calls its statement not dogma and says people need not agree with every word of it.7 Progressive writers range from Borg and Spong, who held Easter true without a physical resurrection, to McLaren, who makes room for those who read it literally.322834

    Common questions

    What is the difference between evangelical and progressive Christianity?

    Evangelical statements of faith call the Bible God's trustworthy word and teach Jesus's virgin birth, death in sinners' place, and bodily resurrection, with salvation through faith in him. One group's statement, ProgressiveChristianity.org's, which the group calls not dogma but a starting point, centers the way of Jesus, values questions over certainty, and sees the Spirit at work in other faiths.

    Is progressive Christianity the same as mainline Protestantism?

    No. Mainline is Pew's name for a group of denominations such as the United Methodist Church and the Episcopal Church. Progressive names an outlook that crosses church lines. In PRRI's 2013 survey, 29 percent of religious progressives were Catholics and 19 percent were white mainline Protestants, and the group also included people of other faiths.

    How many Americans are evangelical, and how many are progressive Christians?

    Pew's survey of 2023 and 2024 counts 23 percent of US adults as evangelical Protestants, sorting people mainly by the denomination they name. A 2015 Lifeway Research survey, counting by four beliefs, found about 30 percent. Neither Pew nor PRRI counts progressive Christians as a group. PRRI's 2013 count of religious progressives, 19 percent, also included Catholics, non-Christians, and others.

    Do progressive Christians believe in the resurrection?

    ProgressiveChristianity.org's Core Values do not mention it. Marcus Borg and John Shelby Spong held Easter true without a physical bodily resurrection. Brian McLaren makes room both for people who read the Easter story literally and for people who do not. No survey this page found measures how many hold each view.

    Do evangelicals agree about women pastors?

    No. The Danvers Statement reserves some governing and teaching roles for men, and the Baptist Faith and Message 2000 limits the pastorate to men. Christians for Biblical Equality holds that women as well as men carry out the church's prophetic, priestly, and royal functions. The Assemblies of God ordains women: 27.6 percent of its ministers in 2022, Christianity Today reported.

    What do evangelical and progressive Christians agree on?

    Both center their faith on Jesus, and both have spoken of sharing bread and the cup in his name. Both call for justice and care for people in need: the Baptist Faith and Message tells Christians to oppose racism, and the Core Values call for peace and justice. Each places itself in the church's long tradition.

    Sources

    1. National Association of Evangelicals. What is an Evangelical?. National Association of Evangelicals. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    2. National Association of Evangelicals. Statement of Faith. National Association of Evangelicals. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    3. The Lausanne Movement. The Lausanne Covenant. The Lausanne Movement, 1974. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    4. Southern Baptist Convention. The Baptist Faith and Message 2000. Southern Baptist Convention, 2000, Articles I and VII. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    5. ProgressiveChristianity.org. Past versions of the Core Values. ProgressiveChristianity.org. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    6. ProgressiveChristianity.org. Our History. ProgressiveChristianity.org. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    7. ProgressiveChristianity.org. The Core Values of Progressive Christianity. ProgressiveChristianity.org, 2022. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    8. Ruth Braunstein, Todd Nicholas Fuist, and Rhys H. Williams. Religion and Progressive Politics in the United States. Sociology Compass 13, no. 2, 2018. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    9. The Marcus J. Borg Foundation. About Us. The Marcus J. Borg Foundation. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    10. Bob Smietana. RIP: John Shelby Spong, former Newark bishop who pushed for LGBTQ+ inclusion, dies at 90. Episcopal News Service (from Religion News Service), 2021. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    11. Brian D. McLaren. Brian D. McLaren (home page). Brian D. McLaren (author's website). Accessed 2026-11-20.
    12. Brian D. McLaren. Why Did Jesus, Moses, the Buddha, and Mohammed Cross the Road? Christian Identity in a Multi-Faith World. Jericho Books, Hachette Book Group (publisher's page), 2012. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    13. Shannon Van Sant. Progressive Christian Writer Rachel Held Evans Dies At 37. NPR, 2019. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    14. Rachel Held Evans. Making Peace with Science. Rachel Held Evans (author's blog), 2009. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    15. Tim Stafford. Evangelical Evolutionists Meet in New York. Christianity Today, 2012. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    16. Rachel Held Evans. Mutuality 2012 Posts. Rachel Held Evans (author's blog), 2012. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    17. Michael G. Maudlin. Women's Roles: New Statement Affirms Equality of Men, Women. Christianity Today, 1989. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    18. Pew Research Center. Religious Landscape Study, chapter 1: Religious identity. Pew Research Center, 2025. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    19. Lifeway Research. NAE, LifeWay Research Publish Evangelical Beliefs Research Definition. Lifeway Research, 2015. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    20. Pew Research Center. Appendix B: Classification of Protestant Denominations. Pew Research Center, 2025. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    21. PRRI. 1-in-5 Americans are 'Religious Progressives'. PRRI, 2013. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    22. World Evangelical Alliance. Who We Are. World Evangelical Alliance. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    23. Marcus J. Borg. American Christians Are Deeply Divided. The Marcus J. Borg Foundation (from the Washington Post's On Faith panel). Accessed 2026-11-20.
    24. International Council on Biblical Inerrancy. The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy. Evangelical Theological Society (hosted copy), 1978. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    25. Marcus J. Borg. What the Bible Is. The Marcus J. Borg Foundation (from his Patheos blog), 2014. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    26. Publishers Weekly. Reading the Bible Again for the First Time: Taking the Bible Seriously but Not Literally (review). Publishers Weekly, 2001. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    27. Rachel Held Evans. Inspired: Slaying Giants, Walking on Water, and Loving the Bible Again. Thomas Nelson (publisher's store page, FaithGateway), 2018. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    28. John Shelby Spong. Charting the New Reformation: The Twelve Theses (Part III). ProgressiveChristianity.org, 2015. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    29. W. Robert Godfrey (Ask Ligonier). What can we learn from the ministry of J. Gresham Machen?. Ligonier Ministries. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    30. J. Gresham Machen. Christianity and Liberalism, Chapter 3: God and Man. Macmillan (1923); Christian Classics Ethereal Library text, 1923. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    31. The Lausanne Movement. The Cape Town Commitment: A Confession of Faith and a Call to Action. The Lausanne Movement, 2010, Part IIB, sections 1 and 2; Part IIC, section 1. Accessed 2026-11-04.
    32. Marcus J. Borg. Easter Again. The Marcus J. Borg Foundation (from his Patheos blog), 2014. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    33. Marcus J. Borg. Reflections on Easter. The Marcus J. Borg Foundation, 2012. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    34. Brian D. McLaren, with his co-hosts. Learning How to See, Season 4, Episode 12: Listener Questions: Jesus and Theology (transcript). Center for Action and Contemplation, 2023, pp. 2 to 4. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    35. Greg Gilbert. Book Review: The Nature of the Atonement: Four Views, ed. by James Beilby and Paul Eddy. 9Marks. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    36. James K. Beilby and Paul R. Eddy, eds.. The Nature of the Atonement: Four Views. InterVarsity Press (IVP Academic), 2006. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    37. Steve Jeffery, Michael Ovey, and Andrew Sach. Pierced for Our Transgressions: Rediscovering the Glory of Penal Substitution. Crossway (publisher's page), 2007. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    38. Marcus J. Borg. Lent and the Cross. The Marcus J. Borg Foundation (from his Patheos blog), 2014. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    39. Thomas Williams. Anselm of Canterbury. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    40. Brian D. McLaren. Foreword to Derek Flood, Healing the Gospel: A Radical Vision for Grace, Justice, and the Cross. Cascade Books, Wipf and Stock (excerpt hosted on the author Derek Flood's site), 2012, Foreword. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    41. Evangelical Alliance (UK), Commission on Unity and Truth among Evangelicals (ACUTE). The Nature of Hell. Evangelical Alliance, 2000. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    42. Evangelical Alliance (UK), Commission on Unity and Truth among Evangelicals (ACUTE). The Nature of Hell: Conclusions and Recommendations. Evangelical Alliance, 2000. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    43. Brian D. McLaren (interviewed). Brian McLaren Extended Interview. Religion and Ethics Newsweekly, PBS, 2005. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    44. Brian D. McLaren. Everything Must Change: When the World's Biggest Problems and Jesus' Good News Collide. Thomas Nelson (publisher's store page, FaithGateway). Accessed 2026-11-20.
    45. Answers in Genesis. Statement of Faith. Answers in Genesis. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    46. Cary Funk. How highly religious Americans view evolution depends on how they're asked about it. Pew Research Center, 2019. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    47. Timothy Keller. The Reason for God: Belief in an Age of Skepticism. Penguin Books (publisher's page), 2008. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    48. Daniel Silliman. Died: Tim Keller, New York City Pastor Who Modeled Winsome Witness. Christianity Today, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    49. Susan Wunderink. Believing in Doubt. Christianity Today, 2008. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    50. Zena Neds-Fox. Review: Evolving in Monkeytown by Rachel Held Evans [Vol. 3, #26]. The Englewood Review of Books, 2010. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    51. Rachel Held Evans. Faith Unraveled: How a Girl Who Knew All the Answers Learned to Ask Questions. Zondervan (publisher's store page, FaithGateway). Accessed 2026-11-20.
    52. Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood. The Danvers Statement. Council on Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, 1988. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    53. Hannah McClellan. Assemblies of God Ordains a Record Number of Women. Christianity Today, 2022. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    54. Rachel Held Evans, with Mimi Haddad. Ask an Egalitarian...(Response). Rachel Held Evans (author's blog), 2012. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    55. Pew Research Center. Religion and Views on LGBTQ Issues and Abortion. Pew Research Center, 2025. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    56. Elon University News. New book by Rebecca Todd Peters explores women's reproductive rights. Elon University, 2018. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    57. J. Gresham Machen. Christianity and Liberalism. Macmillan (1923); Christian Classics Ethereal Library text, 1923, Chapter 1 (Introduction), pp. 2 to 7. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    58. Scot McKnight. Brian McLaren's 'A New Kind of Christianity'. Christianity Today, 2010. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    59. Publishers Weekly. Another Gospel?: A Lifelong Christian Seeks Truth in Response to Progressive Christianity (review). Publishers Weekly, 2020. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    60. Alisa Childers. Another Gospel?. Alisa Childers (author's website). Accessed 2026-11-20.
    61. Rachel Held Evans. So how was your Easter...really?. Rachel Held Evans (author's blog). Accessed 2026-11-20.