See all results on the search page

    The Existence of God: an argument against God

    If God exists, why do some sincere seekers not believe? Divine hiddenness

    The hiddenness argument holds that a perfectly loving God would let everyone open to a relationship with him believe he exists, and that some such people do not believe. J. L. Schellenberg, its leading defender, concludes that no such God exists. Critics answer that God may have reasons to stay hidden, or that perfect love need not take that form.

    • 9 minute read
    • Last reviewed:

    The argument, step by step

    Here the argument's defenders are philosophers who press it, led by J. L. Schellenberg; its critics are philosophers who answer it, such as Michael Rea and Paul Moser. "Divine hiddenness" is the standard term in the literature, though the argument itself rests on facts about who believes.

    For the argumentAgainst the argumentWhat both sides accept

    The argument, as its defenders state it:

    1. Premise 1Some people who are capable of a personal relationship with God fail to believe in God, through no fault of their own.
    2. Premise 2If there is a personal God who is unsurpassably great, there are no such people.
    3. ConclusionSo there is no such God.

    1Premise 1Some people who are capable of a personal relationship with God fail to believe in God, through no fault of their own.

    For the argument

    For the argumentSeekers, whole cultures, and former believers

    J. L. Schellenberg points to honest seekers who remain agnostics or atheists, cultures with no idea of a personal God, early hunter-gatherers, and people who have lost their faith and want it back. He holds it vanishingly unlikely that all of the secular West's hundreds of millions of nonbelievers were resisting God when they first became able to relate to him.1

    For the argumentNonresistance is what matters

    Schellenberg later recast the premise in terms of nonresistance: these nonbelievers have not shut the door on God, for example through careless inquiry or by drifting away with their own consent.1

    For the argumentBelief clusters by country

    Stephen Maitzen noted in 2006 that Saudi Arabia was at least 95 percent Muslim, while Thailand was 95 percent Buddhist and so, he reasoned, at most 5 percent theistic. The motives theists offer to explain nonbelief do not cluster by country, he argues, so culture and politics explain the pattern better than God does.1

    Reply, against the argumentGod may place people where they can believe later

    In a 2008 paper, Jason Marsh offered a reply drawing on Molinism, the view that God knows what any free creature would do in any situation. God might place those who would reject him in this life where they cannot believe, preserving them to come to God later.1

    Reply, for the argumentA troubling way to sort whole peoples

    Maitzen answered Marsh in 2008. The Stanford entry's authors add that many theists find Molinist explanations unappealing, and that, at first glance, they seem to treat whole peoples as those who would not respond to God in this life, whatever God did.1

    Reply, against the argumentPeople learn from one another

    Max Baker-Hytch argues that people depend on one another for much of what they know, which brings real goods, such as trust and shared responsibility. So uneven belief is about as likely if God exists as if not, on a view where a person's eternal destiny does not turn on belief at death.1

    For the argumentEarly humans had no idea of God

    Jason Marsh, in later work, argues that early humans originally had no concept of God, only of limited spirits. Their nonbelief was natural and nonresistant, which he holds is more surprising if God exists than on naturalism, the view that nature is all there is.1

    Reply, against the argumentEarly minds may have leaned toward God

    Some take the cognitive science of religion to support the view that religious impulses friendly to belief in God are universal. Others suggest that early humans' lives may be part of a larger story that gives them meaning, whether or not they could grasp it.1

    Against the argument

    Against the argumentNonbelief may always involve some resistance

    Some answer that everyone has a basic knowledge of God that can be suppressed. John Calvin held that people have a sense of the divine, and Jonathan Edwards that there is enough light for anyone to know God, so that nonbelief comes from impairments people bring on themselves.1

    Reply, for the argumentA denial must answer the evidence

    Schellenberg answers that anyone who denies nonresistant nonbelief must square that denial with his evidence for it. The Stanford entry's authors add, citing Adam Green, Michael Rea, and Michelle Panchuk, that resistance caused by religious trauma and other hurts should deeply concern theists too.1

    2Premise 2If there is a personal God who is unsurpassably great, there are no such people.

    For the argument

    For the argumentPerfect love is always open to relationship

    Schellenberg argues that a perfectly loving God would always be open to a conscious, two-way relationship with every person capable of one. Such a relationship requires believing that God exists, and belief cannot be chosen at will, so God would make sure that anyone who does not resist could believe.1

    Against the argument

    Against the argumentGod may have reasons to wait

    Critics suggest reasons a loving God might delay belief: so that a person's love is not driven by fear or a wish for approval, to protect moral freedom (John Hick, Richard Swinburne), or to keep faith from growing complacent (Soren Kierkegaard) or presumptuous (Blaise Pascal). Others suggest that God wants people to seek and help one another, or does not give belief to those unwilling to be changed by it (Paul Moser).1

    Reply, for the argumentThe relationship itself is the greater good

    Schellenberg and others answer that these goods could be had within a growing relationship with God, or are outweighed by it, since that relationship is the greatest good. Some also ask why God would create resisters and nonbelievers at all.1

    Reply, against the argumentSeveral reasons may work together

    Others reply that no single reason need explain every case, since several may combine. They add that it may be hard for anyone to tell whether a given nonbeliever is truly nonresistant.1

    Against the argumentGod's love may not be a parent's love

    Critics such as Michael Rea point out that many classical theists hold that God is beyond human categories, and so not loving in the human sense the argument needs. Others suggest that perfect love may be more like a surgeon's or a distant grandparent's (Terence Cuneo), or may vary from person to person (Jeff Jordan).1

    Reply, for the argumentThe greatest possible person would love perfectly

    Schellenberg argues that God, as the greatest possible person, would be perfect in love, since, all else being equal, a person perfect in love is greater than one who is not. He has also replied to particular proposals, such as Jordan's view of a love that varies.1

    Against the argumentWe may not know God's reasons

    As with the problem of evil, Michael Bergmann and others argue that we are in no position to tell whether God has reasons for permitting nonresistant nonbelief that are hidden from us. This reply is called skeptical theism.12

    Reply, for the argumentThat skepticism reaches too far

    Schellenberg rejects this reply. Critics of skeptical theism argue that it would also leave believers unsure of moral and religious knowledge; whether it does, the Stanford entry notes, is still debated.12

    Against the argumentA relationship may not need belief

    Some argue that a person could begin a relationship with God through faith, hope, or acceptance rather than firm belief, or could know God as a person without believing a statement about God.1

    Reply, for the argumentBelief is the better foundation

    Others ask whether such states are as good a basis for a relationship as belief, and why a perfectly loving God would give less than the best. Schellenberg has restated his argument so that it also covers people who lack these other states.1

    3ConclusionSo there is no such God.

    What both sides acceptThe conclusion follows from the two premises, so the replies question the premises or the idea of God behind them. The argument concerns a personal God who loves perfectly.1

    For the argument

    For the argumentHiddenness strengthens the problem of evil

    Some argue that if God's reasons for a person's suffering were beyond their grasp, God would at least assure them of his love. That many sufferers do not believe God exists, they hold, supports a key step in William Rowe's argument from evil.1

    Reply, against the argumentThe link can also help theists

    Others use the link in theism's favor. Swinburne argues that people's deep responsibility for one another explains why God permits some nonbelief, as it explains some sin and suffering. Travis Dumsday argues that a good reason to permit nonbelief would also give God reason not to undo the effects of wrongdoing at every turn, since that would make his existence plain, and so reason to permit some suffering.1

    Against the argument

    Against the argumentOther evidence may outweigh it

    Some grant that nonbelief gives atheism some weight, but hold that other things give theism much more.1

    Where does the argument come from?

    The experience of God's hiddenness is ancient, but the argument from it is recent.1 Texts of the Hebrew Bible lament that God does not appear, two Christian Gospels portray Jesus, in his cry from the cross, as experiencing abandonment by God (Mark 15:34; Matthew 27:46), and mystics of many theistic traditions have described a dark night of the soul.13 The Book of Isaiah calls God a God who hides himself (Isaiah 45:15).45 Blaise Pascal's Pensees (1670) gave reasons why God might stay hidden, and Soren Kierkegaard (1844) argued that belief given too soon could leave faith complacent or shallow.1

    The modern debate took shape with J. L. Schellenberg's book Divine Hiddenness and Human Reason (1993).1 Daniel Howard-Snyder and Adam Green, in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, write that Schellenberg has shaped the debate more than anyone else.1 He later restated the argument in terms of nonresistance (2007 and 2015).1 Stephen Maitzen (2006) added an argument from the uneven spread of belief across countries, and Jason Marsh (2013) one from the nonbelief of early humans.1

    Across traditions

    Several faiths speak of God as hidden, or give reasons why God is not plainly known. Apart from Christian thinkers, the sources used for this page record no answers from these faiths aimed at Schellenberg's argument itself.

    Buddhism. Schellenberg's argument concerns a personal God who loves perfectly.1 Buddhist teaching, as Nyanaponika Thera reads the Pali canon, denies that there is a personal, eternal, all-powerful creator of this kind.6 Nyanaponika also writes that the meditative states which mystics of many faiths take as experiences of the divine do not, on the Buddhist view, give evidence of a personal God.6

    Christianity. Christian thinkers supply many of the replies on the map. Pascal held that God hides so that people do not relate to him with presumption and so that they feel the wretchedness of life without him, and Kierkegaard worried that faith could grow complacent.1 John Calvin held that every person has a sense of the divine, and Jonathan Edwards that there is sufficient light for anyone to know God.1 Paul's letter to the Romans teaches that God's unseen qualities have been plain to see since the creation of the world (Romans 1:20).13

    Hinduism. In the Bhagavad Gita, Krishna says that, veiled by his own mystic power, he is not manifest to all, and that the deluded world does not know him (7.25).7 He adds that beings are deluded from birth by the pairs of opposites that arise from desire and aversion, and that those whose sins have ended are freed from this delusion and worship him (7.27 to 7.28).7

    Islam. Islamic teaching holds that every person is created with fitra, a nature that holds belief in God's oneness (Quran 30:30).89 A hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari, a Sunni collection, teaches that every child is born upon fitra and that parents then raise the child in another faith.8 Al-Kafi, a Shia collection, reports one of the imams, named there as Abu Abdillah, explaining fitra as belief in God's oneness placed in human nature.9

    Judaism. The Torah speaks of hester panim, the hiding of God's face, as a punishment (Deuteronomy 31:17).45 Tamir Granot, in a lesson for Yeshivat Har Etzion, reads the Talmud (Hagigah 5a) as treating it as part of the bond between Jews and God even apart from sin.4 Eliezer Berkovits, writing after the Holocaust, held that hiddenness belongs to the way God is present in the world.4 On his view, God's hiding makes room for human responsibility and freedom, which God's overwhelming presence would undermine.4

    The Latter-day Saint faith. Latter-day Saint teaching explains why people in this life do not remember having lived with God before birth.10 The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints teaches that before birth, in a council in heaven, God's children learned that a veil would cover their memories of their heavenly home.10 This was necessary, it teaches, so that they could use their agency to choose good or evil without being swayed by the memory of living with God, who would help them recognize the truth when they heard it again on earth.10

    Common questions

    What is the argument from divine hiddenness?

    The argument from divine hiddenness, defended chiefly by J. L. Schellenberg, holds that a perfectly loving God would always be open to a relationship with every person capable of one, which requires believing that God exists. Since some people who do not resist God still do not believe, Schellenberg concludes that no such God exists.

    What is nonresistant nonbelief?

    Nonresistant nonbelief is Schellenberg's term for people who do not believe that God exists but have not closed themselves off from God, for example through careless inquiry or by drifting away with their own consent. He points to seekers who remain agnostic, whole cultures, and former believers who want their faith back.

    How do theists answer the hiddenness argument?

    Theist critics answer that God may have good reasons to wait, such as protecting moral freedom or keeping faith from being driven by fear; that perfect love need not be like a parent's love; that we may not know God's reasons; or that a relationship with God may not require firm belief.

    Read next

    Sources

    1. Daniel Howard-Snyder and Adam Green. Hiddenness of God. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2022. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    2. Timothy Perrine. Skeptical Theism. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.
    3. The Holy Bible, King James Version (1769 standard text). eBible.org, 1769. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    4. Tamir Granot. Faith and the Holocaust, Lesson 42: Rabbi Eliezer Berkovits, Faith after the Holocaust: Divine Providence and Free Choice (part I). Yeshivat Har Etzion, 2015. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    5. Jewish Publication Society of America. The Holy Scriptures According to the Masoretic Text. The Jewish Publication Society of America, 1917. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    6. Nyanaponika Thera. Buddhism and the God-idea. Buddhist Publication Society, via Access to Insight, 1994, opening paragraphs. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    7. Kashinath Trimbak Telang. The Bhagavadgita, with the Sanatsugatiya and the Anugita (Sacred Books of the East, volume 8). Clarendon Press, 1882. Accessed 2026-10-28.
    8. Sahih al-Bukhari 1358 (English translation). Hadith Unlocked, hadith 1358. Accessed 2026-10-29.
    9. al-Kulayni, trans. Muhammad Sarwar. al-Kafi, volume 2, book 1, chapter 6: Creation of the Creatures with Belief in Oneness of Allah in Their Nature. Thaqalayn, hadiths 1 to 3. Accessed 2026-10-29.
    10. Council in Heaven, Topics and Questions (2023). The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, 2023. Accessed 2026-11-20.